HPV vaccine approved despite dominionists
The HPV vaccine is one that has been particularly newsworthy, as it is only the second vaccine that can legitimately be said to be an anticancer vaccine (the other being the hepatitis-B shot) and--much like the hep-B shot, now accepted generally as part of childhood vaccination--has been the center of quite the firestorm among the dominionist community. HPV is the primary cause of both cervical cancer in female girls and of anal cancer in gay men (with similar rates of infection for both) as well as being the primary cause of cancer of the penis in all men, gay or straight; it also happens to be one of the primary tools used in dominionist "Scared Celibate" campaigns. One of the primary reasons that dominionists have fought approval of HPV vaccination is the claim that this will give teenage girls, in essence, a "license to fornicate" and remove one of the primary tools they use to scare kids away from sex (namely, the idea that they'll get CANCER and that condoms Will Not Save Them, and boys will lose their Naughty Bits). This is despite, of course, the fact that there are just as many STDs out there that are likely to discourage kids (not the least of these being HIV, but also things like herpes and the like).
Examples of how the dominionist movement used HPV to fight the notion of even the effectiveness of condoms is noted in an article in The Nation: Christian conservatives have a special reason to be less than thrilled about the HPV vaccine. Although not as famous as chlamydia or herpes, HPV has the distinction of not being preventable by condoms. It's Exhibit A in those gory high school slide shows that try to scare kids away from sex, and it is also useful for undermining the case for rubbers generally--why bother when you could get HPV anyway? In 2000, Congressman (now Senator) Tom Coburn of Oklahoma, who used to give gruesome lectures on HPV for young Congressional aides, even used HPV to propose warning labels on condoms. With HPV potentially eliminated, the antisex brigade will lose a card it has regarded as a trump unless it can persuade parents that vaccinating their daughters will turn them into tramps, and that sex today is worse than cancer tomorrow. According to New Scientist, 80 percent of parents want the vaccine for their daughters--but their priests and pastors haven't worked them over yet. The dominionist groups in opposition to the HPV vaccine were some of the most well known--among them, the Family Research Council, Focus on the Family, and Concerned Women for America all issued statements urging the FDA not to approve Gardisil--on the grounds it would undercut their efforts to "scare kids celibate". Most of those groups in fact still actively oppose requiring vaccination. A strictly voluntary vaccination would be largely useless, public-health-wise; to give an analogy, we would never have eliminated smallpox were it not for mandatory vaccination, and in fact polio has had a resurgence in Africa and mumps and measles in the US specifically because of people "opting out" of vaccinations for religious reasons. (And yes, some dominionists are increasingly opting out of most vaccination, claiming anything cultured in "human diploid cell" culture is made from aborted babies"; this pretty much includes most modern live vaccines, including human rabies vaccine (and the same site claims rabies immunoglobulin also comes from "aborted babies"); in fact, quite a few of the groups promoting this stuff also offer pre-written exemption forms and occasionally use blatant scripture-twisting to justify this, claiming even that vaccination is "witchcraft". One expects that if they are misfortunate enough to have their children bitten by a rabid animal they will allow their child to suffer one of the most horrifying ways possible for a human being to die. (Warning--last two links are to graphic and highly disturbing pictures and videos of humans dying of rabies.)) Very interestingly, the "Pill", the hepatitis-B shot, and in fact every single tool out there that would potentially make sex safer has been opposed by dominionists on identical grounds; when hep-B vaccination became mandatory as a term for school admission (a necessary evil due to hep-B being endemic in certain groups--such as immigrants and Native American populations--and kids being unfortunate enough to be born with hep-B in many instances) dominionists protested their kids getting the hep-B shot for what it still depicted in the dominionist community as "a disease mostly junkies and gays get". In fact, the fact that the hep-B jab is now required has been used by dominionists to encourage parents to use correspondence-schools. The other major reason is that HPV is in fact one of the things that anti-gay groups in the dominionist community use to justify what increasingly are de facto progroms against LGBT individuals--including the "Protection of Marriage" amendment which recently failed passage in the Senate. Among other things, Paul Cameron--and the AFA and its affiliates who parrot Cameron, NARTH, Lifesite.net, Focus on the Family, and others--have used the incidence of HPV-related anal cancer to claim gay men have a far shorter average lifespan (in fact, the rate is only higher than for straight women if gay men with HPV are coinfected with HIV; otherwise, the rate per population is nearly identical to that of women with HPV-related cervical cancer) and to promote the idea of gay men getting "gay bowel disease". (In other words, with an effective HPV vaccine, it'd practically eliminate their claim that gay men will get anal cancer.)
Fortunately, for once, the FDA has listened to reason rather than dominionists: The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) today announced the approval of Gardasil, the first vaccine developed to prevent cervical cancer, precancerous genital lesions and genital warts due to human papillomavirus (HPV) types 6, 11, 16 and 18. The vaccine is approved for use in females 9-26 years of age. Gardasil was evaluated and approved in six months under FDA's priority review process--a process for products with potential to provide significant health benefits. In addition to its initial approval in women, a phase III trial will be conducted regarding the effectiveness of HPV vaccination of men. Full prescribing info and a FAQ on Gardisil is at the FDA's website for biological products.
HPV vaccine approved despite dominionists | 3 comments (3 topical, 0 hidden)
HPV vaccine approved despite dominionists | 3 comments (3 topical, 0 hidden)
|
||||||||||||
|